Who We Are

Our Philosophy on Service.

As an enterprising boutique real estate company serving a continually growing client base developed over the past 15 years, we have sold over $47 million in real estate since 2016. We work hard to provide personalized attention to each client to assist in all facets of the process of buying, selling, and often both - to make it easier on YOU - our most valued asset! 

With our combined 80+ years of real estate knowledge and experience, our company culture is founded on always putting our clients first. We are honest, we listen, we care, we demonstrate integrity, we offer friendship, and we perform individualized personal services, as no client ever requires the same services. We love being able to help and become a part of something so important to YOU!

Carefully curated team.

Our team has been carefully curated to provide exceptional customer service based on integrity, honesty and industry experience. We continue to earn our clients’ loyalty and repeat business, because of how we strive to guide and protect our clientele through each transaction - and beyond.

Our agents appreciate a work environment that measures success by happy customers. Additionally, we provide support to each other so that all our clients may benefit from our collective experience. We invite you to view testimonials of what past clients have to say.

Our most valued asset – You.

We care deeply about you and what is important to you, such as your timeline, desired price, terms, a smooth transaction, your personal items, and of course, your prized possession: Your Property. We’ll make sure it is well cared for and treated respectfully throughout the process. Earning your trust and loyalty is the biggest reward we could ever ask for or receive. And, we’ll work hard to earn it.

Please call or email anytime and let us help.

Testimonials

"Property Cape Cod Real Estate represents what a great real estate firm should be all about which is excellent Service, Expertise, and then on top of that some TLC! I used Tia Lilly as an agent in buying our vacation home on the Cape and then hired her agency to manage my property and summer rentals. I have lots of gray hair as I have bought and sold property in various states and overseas so I know an exceptional real estate firm when I experience it, and this is truly an exceptional real estate firm."

Michael K. Block

"Having purchased many homes in my life, I have learned that without the “right” real estate agent to look after your best interests, the process can be very stressful and difficult. Tia is an amazing agent. Her attention to detail and her ability to listen puts her at the top of all the real estate agents I have ever dealt with. We contacted her, explained to her what we were looking for and she went to work to find us the perfect home. She is extremely conscientious and detail oriented and did not stop working for us until every detail was taken care of right up to the point of closing. I would highly recommend her services to anyone buying or selling a home on Cape Cod."

Mitchell and Jackie Gallinger

"I have given Tia Lilly the highest rating for all categories of professional skills to fully express my complete satisfaction with her assistance through the buying process, Not only did she assist in negotiation and sales arrangements with the seller, but also provided valuable contacts and facilitated home inspection and evaluation, property insurance and closing arrangements. This agent was willing to personally trudge through the snow of February 2015 to take photographs on site when we were unable to do this ourselves."

Gary Wells and Terry Tiringer

“Tia was referred to us when we contracted to purchase a home in Osterville. The word was that Tia was an “expert” on properties in that area. That proved to be both correct, and an understatement of what she brings to the table. How was she?  AWESOME! Tia’s approach was exactly what was needed during our search. Not only is she knowledgeable as to various areas, but also certain local customs and legal requirements. She quickly established herself as a member of our “team.” Tia is extremely knowledgeable, and worked seamlessly to stay on top of every aspect of the purchase.  She proved to be responsive and available to answer questions or address needs and concerns at any time. Moreover, Tia has proven to be a much needed resource when seeking recommendations as to contractors post-closing.

But what's even more impressive is that the commitment didn't end with the closing, beginning with making arrangements to have out driveway plowed when we got hit with a snowstorm on the day of our closing! In short - As Good as they Come!

David Bogan

“When my husband and I decided to sell our home in Centerville, a co-worker of his recommended Tia. I believe she helped his daughter buy a new home. From the first day Tia, was absolutely wonderful.  She was always in constant contact with us, always available when we had questions and if she wasn't available immediately she would always get back to us quickly. Tia knows the Cape extremely well.

It was a stressful selling a home and buying a home but having someone like Tia took that stress away. As happy as I was when our home sold and we bought another home, I was a little sad that I probably wouldn't be talking to Tia anymore.  That didn't happen, we have developed a great friendship. Not only did we buy and sell we have now have a great friend. I would highly recommend her if you are either buying or selling a home, or if you are doing both. You will not find a better real estate agent.”

Nancy & Jamie Booth

"Karen is amazing. I have known her personally and professionally for many years. She has been helpful in several of my real estate transactions. Her wisdom, experience, kindness, and attention to detail are her greatest attributes."

ELLEN CARTY

"Karen is efficient and quick to respond to emails and calls. She took care of selling my house so that I had little to do. She is also pleasant and friendly. I am happy to recommend Karen."

BEVERLY LORIE

"Karen Lilly is absolutely wonderful to work with. My husband and I have been working with Karen for the past three-four years. It's a collaborative effort when we work. She hears what we're both looking for and what we're not saying and goes after it for us. If it's not available at the time, she continues to monitor the location for something we may be interested in. If I see something out there we run it by Karen and she's off knocking on doors, writing letters or calling up and finding out all she can about the location. She's the hardest working realtor that we've been so lucky to work with. Even though she is working with many clients, we're always made to feel like we're the only ones."

JOAN BARTHE

"Karen was the listing agent in an investment house, owned by my parents, that was successfully sold in the fall of 2012. I would highly recommend her, particularly in a situation where extra care is required. She continually went above and beyond performing tasks and problem solving that were arguably beyond the scope of her obligation. She was excellent!"

ZILLOW USER9939682

"It was a real pleasure to have Dawn Andalft-Newman as our agent. She has extensive knowledge of the area, is very friendly, is careful with all the details, and is always available to respond to a phone call, text message or email. She is driven and quick in getting into action. We felt completely supported through the whole process.

She will always be our agent for the Cape and we certainly will recommend Dawn Andalft-Newman to friends and family looking for property on Cape Cod."

ANDREA BENETIZ

"Catherine treated my parents like they were family so that I always felt comfortable and knew their best interests were the highest priority. My parents had a very challenging situation but Catherine never hesitated, never wavered, and provided constant reassurance that she could handle it. I could never have managed selling the house from my distant location without her help. She was always in my corner and I will be forever grateful."

MATTHEW G

"Thank you, Catherine, so much for your professionalism, support, and expertise in handling the sale of my home. I really appreciate all that you did for me."

JANET G